Review: The Scorpio Races – Maggie Stiefvater

Synopsis from Goodreads.
It happens at the start of every November: the Scorpio Races. Riders attempt to keep hold of their water horses long enough to make it to the finish line. Some riders live. Others die.

At age nineteen, Sean Kendrick is the returning champion. He is a young man of few words, and if he has any fears, he keeps them buried deep, where no one else can see them.

Puck Connolly is different. She never meant to ride in the Scorpio Races. But fate hasn’t given her much of a chance. So she enters the competition — the first girl ever to do so. She is in no way prepared for what is going to happen.

I didn’t think I’d get on with Ms Stiefvater. Partly because it just took me about five minutes to spell her name right, but also because I’ve heard things about her other series that kind of made me think that her writing wouldn’t be for me.

Not negative reviews, not at all. You know Maja, right? Of course you do, she’s brilliant and she’s the biggest Ms S fan that I know of and her reviews (here, here and here) for these books are absolutely wonderful. You’d think if anyone could persuade me to give YA paranormal a bash, it would be her. But alas, I just don’t think they’re for me. Sometimes books just aren’t.

So I was reluctant to start this one. But then so many wonderful reviews from people I would trust with picking my future book list started appearing and I thought “Huh. Why not?”

So I started reading it. And wow.

Like Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo, The Scorpio Races is definitely a book that will go down as a bonnet eater*. I have heard a lot about Ms S’ writing but the snippets I’ve read got me all worried. I thought it was going to be flowery and eye-roll inducing. I guess, with a story like this (again, evil horses… gnashing at each other? Come on..), to make it work, you really have to set the scene and you have to make your readers really believe in the story you’re telling.
And.. again… evil horses… on a beach… gnashing at each other… and eating people.

OK, let’s just talk about that. I feel like it’s the huge evil horse in the room and we need to address it… before it eats us. Seriously, this book is probably going to be the most difficult book to recommend to people.

Jo: Oh hey, you should really read this book! It’s amazing, really it is. I mean… it’s just brilliant. The writing is fantastic, the characters are so good and…what? Oh the story…. Well… there’s these horses and….well, they eat people… and possibly each other. But mostly human face.

Friend: *backs away slowly*

Anyway, evil horses aside, let’s talk about the writing again. Wow. Like I was saying before, if you’re going to go out with the story, you might need to go out there with the descriptions and I was really, really nervous that Ms S would be piling it on. Cramming metaphors here, there and everywhere. But in fact, the writing here was really stripped back, subtle, beautiful and almost raw in places. This book is epic, and I don’t mean that in the way that people say it nowadays (people like… um… me) I mean, epic in the original sense of the word.

The writing perfectly set up the world and didn’t overwhelm the story which, actually, didn’t seem as farfetched as I originally thought.
I’m not saying that I believed there are gnashy horses lurking underneath the surf of Britain’s beaches… but let’s say I was on a remote wind-swept island where the locals are a bit… odd. Well, I’d definitely think twice about going for a paddle.
The only quibble I had with this was that I wish the perspectives had been more equal. I didn’t think of this story as Puck’s, yet she got more airtime. I wish Sean, who was possibly my favourite out of the two, had pushed through a bit more. There seem to be a lot of “boys with…” in YA fiction. Boys with scars, boys with bread, boys with… *cough* tridents. But I don’t think it’s too much of a stretch to say that “the boy with blood-red horse” is just as brilliant as they are.

It’s just that his whole backstory and his personality were just so vivid and wonderful I found myself wishing the whole story was told from his perspective. But I guess that’s always going to be the trouble when I always fall for the strong and silent type, right?

I did love the interaction between Sean and Puck though. I loved their conversation and I loved how understated their relationship was. Also, it’s so incredibly refreshing to actually get why two YA characters want to kiss each other in the first place.

So yeah, consider me completely surprised and truly smitten. Although I can safely say I will never read Linger, Wither etc, I can see why so many people love Ms Steivf… Ms Stie..… Ms S. Her writing is so restrained yet beautiful and this is probably the most original story I’ve ever read. If all of my lovely Ms S cheerleaders read another one of hers that reads like this one (The Raven Boys, maybe?) please just chuck it in my direction.

Unless it’s in hardback because… ouch.

*Bonnet Eater: A book that I think I’m going to hate and I say that I will eat my Reader’s Bonnet if I end up liking it….  And gosh, did I like this book. Consider my bonnet eaten.

12 thoughts on “Review: The Scorpio Races – Maggie Stiefvater

  1. I am an unapologetic Maggie S fan (and I am not a paranormal reader at all) and the Scorpio Races was my favorite of hers… until I read The Raven Boys last week. It has all of the magic of SR but it’s more complex and more mysterious and we get the perspectives of a whole group of people in a really deft manner.

    Anyway… welcome to the club, Jo!

  2. I’m listening to the audio book of this right now to and from work. Im enjoying it as much as I enjoyed reading it. And I love Sean. I have a major book crush right there. I love the quiet passionate ones ;)

    I read the first of her Shiver series and was bored, but on the strength if this I’ve ordered The Raven Boys, I just hope it’s another Scorpio Races!

  3. Hey! Corr would never eat you! He is so nice and gentle and tame… until you turn your back on him and he bites your arm right off. :D

    Hah, this review kicks ass. I had problems convincing people to read this, and I don’t mean just you. I mean other poor, unsuspecting, normal people like my sister. Trying to explain that this FABULOUS book is about horses that come out of the sea and eat people… well, not as easy you’d think.

    I wanted more Sean time too. I loved Puck, she made perfect sense to me, but Sean was the one that came right out of those pages and stood in front of me. I was oddly protective towards him, I still am. In that, he’s a lot like Froi, he appeals to my maternal instinct.

    Anyway, I hate to say I “told you so” but… wait. No, I really don’t. TOLD YOU SO!

  4. Jo, I’ve been thinking the EXACT same thing! I’ve avoiding Ms. S (seriously, her name is SO hard to spell) ever since I heard that The Wolves of Mercy Falls was essentially Twilight except a Team Jacob version and even though Maja’s brilliant reviews of her books have been glaring at me, I never bothered to pick anything up by Ms. S! I did recently pick up Scorpio Races from a friend though and it’s been sitting on my shelves, so I guess I had better get to it! I’m so glad you enjoyed this one, so I have a good feeling now about beginning it myself! :) Brilliant review! :D

    Ivy Book Bindings

  5. Beautiful review Jo I haven’t had the best reading experience with Stiefvater’s books either, but I’ve heard a lot of great things about the book and simply how it blows you away! It sounds a lot different from my typical sort of books that I would pick up, but I think I would like it! :)

  6. Yay, I’m glad you loved this! I really enjoyed Puck and Sean’s relationship, too!

    And you said “I will never read Linger, Wither etc” but Wither isn’t one of the TWoMF series titles ;) And I think you’d like them, Grace and Sam are a lovely couple – Maggie knows how to write about love in a beautiful way

  7. Yeah, I wasn’t overly impressed with Shiver. But there was a voice in my head telling me I NEEDED to give this book a shot anyway, and I’ve never been so glad I did! This ended up being my fave 2011 read and I still get chills thinking about how atmospheric it is. Glad you loved it :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s